Federalism: Competing Maps
I am taking a second look at it. If we were to get federalism now, that map might look something like this. I never disliked this map. It is just that I offered a competing map of three states and 25 districts. Whatever we will finally end up with is going to have to be a result of a democratic process.
But when the Pahadi Bahun establishment is opposed to absolutely any kind of federalim, this ethnic federalism map might be the only to go for. That would be a counterbalance. And we should push for this map to be adopted for interim federalism.
प्रस्तािवत संिवधान
The constituent assembly is going to have to look at the federalism question all over again no matter what we go for now.
At this point we just have to make sure the elections to the constituent assembly are free, fair and representative. Let the people decide who they want to speak on their behalf. Ultimately it is not through street protests that we want to shape up the country, but through the ballot box.
Street protests are for when the democratic process fundamentally fails, like it has failed in the case of the interim constitution.
Democracy is one person, one vote. What we had after 1990 was a deviation from that basic promise.
Federalism: Four Layers Or Three Layers
Interim Federalism
Federal Republic Guaranteed
Critiquing Pitambar Sharma's Federalism
Pitambar Sharma's Federalism
Federalism: Competing Maps
RPP For Federalism Ahead of UML, NC And NC(D)
My Federalism Is Economic, Scientific, Not Ethnic
Why It Is Important To Me The Congress Takes Up A Federal Republic
UML Inching Towards Federalism
Monarchy, Army, Federalism
In The News
Another protester killed in police firing in Bara NepalNews One Majir Alam Ansari, 25, of Raghunathpur VDC died on the spot as bullet fired by the riot police hit him ...... Three protesters injured the incident have been identified as Jitendra Yadav, Surendra Kushwaha and Harihar Mahato. ..... A 12-hour curfew is in effect in Kalaiya Municipality from 8 am after sporadic protests continued around the town from early morning. One protester was killed in police firing there on Saturday.
Eight parties discuss Terai crisis: Tuesday’s meeting to come up with 'concrete decisions' The issue of federal system also figured in the debate
Kamal Thapa arrested Kantipur will be kept under preventive detention at Hanuman Dhoka for further questioning .... discussed carrying out the actions recommended by the Rayamajhi report- the panel formed to investigate atrocities committed during the April movement- against former ministers of the king appointed cabinet
Eight-party meet Tuesday to tackle Terai unrest
Subba says he will prove his nationality to Supreme Court
Terai unrest continues, Minister Tripathi resigns
Drastic changes in education system soon two streams of education - professional and general - right from primary to higher secondary level. ...... a student who finds formal education boring and unsuitable can just quit and join professional education. ..... Students will have to sit for SLC exams only after completing class 12. ...... children with different mother tongues will be provided with curricula in their own preferred language. ..... teachers too will be provided with training to teach in different languages. ..... the pass marks will be 40 instead of the current 32 out of 100 ..... comprehensive assessment system till class seven, which means evaluating and promoting a child according to his/her overall performance and knowledge instead of examination only
Journos, media houses attacked BIRGUNJ, Jan 29 - Demonstrators in the protests called by Madhesi People's Rights Forum (MPRF) Sunday attacked journalists and media houses here in the town. ...... including Post correspondents. .... A rally that defied curfew orders vandalized local FM station Radio Birgunj and branch office of the Federation of Nepalese Journalists (FNJ). The station's broadcast was disrupted for some hours following the attack. Some 60 to 70 protesters stormed the station, according to Dipendra Chauhan, news coordinator of the station. Protesters also vandalized four motorcycles of the FM station, some equipment of BBC Radio Nepali Service and Communication Corner. ...... After vandalizing Radio Birgunj, the mob was heading toward Narayani FM. ...... managing director of the station Govinda Devkota. ..... "This is a conspiracy hatched by regressive forces against the newly-established loktantra," said Chauhan, who is also a member of Press Council, adding, "Journalists will however tackle it patiently." ...... Protesters had brutally beaten up photojournalist Ram Sarraf earlier in the morning. ..... the group also beat up journalists Dhruva Sah and Bhuvan Jha. ..... editors and publishers of seven daily newspapers have declared in unison they will not publish their editions from Tuesday in protest of the attack against journalists and media houses. ...... Journalists have also blamed the police forces of being mute spectators during the incidents. ..... irate demonstrators also burnt down a police unit at Gandak area, survey and customs offices, and vandalized some private houses. ...... In Bara, journalists could not go outside to cover news and take photographs of demonstrations ...... issuing a statement, MPRF Sunsari chapter has urged journalists and human rights activists to cover news of the protests and monitor activities without any fear and terror.
Indian dies in police baton charge
Begin dialogue to resolve Terai unrest for timely CA elections: NC-D The NC-D meeting today at Maharajgunj urged Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala to immediately call an eight party meet to discuss the problems and demands of the Madheshi people. ...... Seeking the attention of the agitating Madheshi People’s Rights Forum’s attention regarding the infiltration of unruly and violent groups in the ongoing protests, the NC-D today appealed all sides to maintain peace and goodwill in the nation. ..... a state reconfiguration based on a federal setup put forward by the Madheshi community be included in the interim constitution. ..... the need for a serious discussion over the notion of a proportional electorate system and determination of electoral constituencies based on population figures to seek a political outlet to the present crisis. ..... NC-D General Secretary Bimelendra Nidhi, central committee members Bijaya Kumar Gacchadar, Purna Bahadur Khadka, Uma Kant Chaudhary and Dr Prakash Sharan Mahat among others had put forward their views as on the ways to resolve the Terai unrest during the meet.
Nepal minister quits over Terai Indian Express, India
Senior Nepal Minister resigns
Seventh protester killed in Nepal violence
2 protesters shot by police die in southern Nepal; death toll at 8
Protester killed in attack on police station in Nepal
"We will put Nepal's relations with India on a new and equal footing" Hindu, India
Nepal's Maoists call on US to remove them from `terrorist' list
Nepal Congress Leader Dies OhmyNews International, South Korea
Nepal Congress Leader Nona Koirala Dies
Nepal`s leading female pro-democracy activist dies at 78
Nona Koirala, Nepal's most influential woman, dead
Let the points below be taken into consideration:a) Unless the Peoples in Madheshi Movement shun violence; there shall virtually be no support to the movement from our part;b) Should Madheshi Movement Peoples move on peacefully, however, we would take the movement targeted against the age old fundamentalism, which needs to be crushed into pieces;C) Those who until recently resorted to violence, got tagged themselves as 'criminals', brought deaths to more than 13 thousand Nepalis and now 'share power' at the apex and dictate the government not to hold talks - are ridiculous guys;d) Also those who charge against the People in Madheshi Movement as 'Thugs', 'criminals' or 'people without any base' seem to have lost their own 'bases in Terai' and do not appear wanting the long over-due Terai Problems resolved;e) The Madheshi peoples who have suffered much, have the right to peacefully choose what they prefer most;f) The larger mass of disadvantaged communities across South Asia including Nepal is deprived of basic human rights therefore such uprising was inevitable. To broker peace amidst the current violent conditions and flourish prosperity in the region the 'Carterian apartheid' must be abolished; http://nipforum.org/carter_palestine_apartheid.pdf g) Let there be immediate dialogues and demands fulfilled reasonably;h) Most importantly, care must be taken as the Hindu Nationalist BJP' having won Bihar may have deep interest in Nepal's current socio-political conditions;********************************* Nepal-US Indigenous Peoples' Forum Inc.14 Allen StreetSomerville. MA 02143United States of America
Kamal Thapaharule Teraima bitanda machhayako ho bhane uslai girfatar gareko thikkai hola.
Kamal Thapaharu matrale tyasto aant garna saklan ? Usko pachhadi aru pani holan. Tin lai pani arrest garnu paryo.
Resolve the Terai crisis at the earliest guys !
Yes, the BJP has won Bihar. Caution !
Dear Rana dai,
Very good proposition! I really appreciate it. Those issues, among several others, must be well taken care of (as you've rightly said), if we all aspire of creating a conflict-free society where every one can exercise equal rights. Nevertheless, there is a need to bring down the awful activities happening in the nation. Destroying properties (e.g. destroying the statue of the national icons), harassing people, and abusing socalled PAHADIAS are not the way to put pressure on the government. Hope you all will also come up with benign strategies to managing the movement so that other group of people do not have to suffer.
You can also read an interesting analysis on the following site. Hope you all will like it too.
http://www.mysansar.com/?p=1255
Regards,
No comments:
Post a Comment