Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Maintaining Perspectives On Ethnicity, Race And The Good Old Dollar

English: Nitish Kumar
English: Nitish Kumar (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
(published in Vishwa Sandesh)

Maintaining Perspectives On Ethnicity, Race And The Good Old Dollar
By Paramendra Bhagat (

All you have to do is meet a few bad mannered Madhesis in New York City, and that really gives you perspectives on ethnicity and race. Madhesis are not Bahuns, not Pahadis, Madhesis are not white. All you have to do is meet a few bad mannered Bahuns in NYC and you come out ahead on the social dynamics of the situation. Bahuns are not Indian.

There is the immediate, and then there is that which happens or needs to happen 10,000 miles away. There is the New York City thing, the city that is the Kathmandu of the world, the capital city where every town on earth is represented. And then there is Nepal.

I have fond memories of putting my efforts into Nepal’s democracy movement a few years ago. And I have vivid memories of seeing deep hostility from some of the comrades of that same movement when the Madhesi movement took off. It is sad that the constituent assembly was not able to give Nepal a new constitution in two years, or even four. I have a feeling neither of the two sides might cross the two-thirds majority mark, and all the major parties will end up facing a similar situation to what they faced in the last assembly, which is that compromise is essential to how democracy works. You can’t get everything you want, and so you also have to listen to the other side and try and seek common ground.

When I personally drew a map for a federal Nepal in 2005 it had three economic states: Koshi, Gandaki and Karnali. The Terai got a proportionate representation in the parliament based on population. And I drew that map because I have recognized as far back as I can remember that poverty is the number one political issue in Nepal. It is number one, number two, number three. There are Arab states where you draw a handsome annual salary for simply being a citizen. I am a believer in Nepal’s hydro potential. There’s the petro dollar, and then there’s the hydro dollar.

But over the years I have come to appreciate the need for ethnic federalism. I have personal experiences going back to my high school years in Kathmandu that more than convince me the systemic disadvantages faced by the DaMaJaMa – Dalit, Madhesi, Janajati, Mahila – in Nepal are very real. A compromise would mean Nepal might end up neither with a pure geographic federalism, nor with a pure ethnic federalism. And I would rather the map came out sooner rather than later. The longer Nepal takes to finalize its constitution and the federalism question, longer the delay to focusing on economic issues. Right now Nepal is missing out. China is forging ahead. India is forging ahead. Nepal sadly lags behind. What Nepal needs more than anything else is a Nitish Kumar, someone who would make a singular focus on economic development and give double digit growth rates, year in year out. The longer we dwell on issues of ethnicity and federalism, greater the delay to such years of rapid growth.

I had never imagined Bihar would see the day it is seeing today. This is like Alabama became the top American state economically. That same Bihar depends on Nepal to become flood free and energy rich in the future. But Nepal and India have never so far managed to reach such heights of cooperation. Nepal and India are friendly as in the two countries are not likely to go to war, but cooperation has been poor over the decades. In Nepal the false nationalism is suspicious of everything that looks Indian, and that sentiment has permanent hold on a segment of the population. In India the bureaucrats running the foreign policy machinery spend too much energy on being a regional hegemon and not enough on aspiring to be a global power by taking the immediate neighbors into confidence.

But the economic engine is a beautiful thing. I f diversity is the reason for civil wars, New York City would shame Bosnia, but it does not. It is because people in NYC are too busy chasing the dollar. A laser like focus on the economy is the best way for Nepal to get past its ethnically complicated past. All you need is a simple, progressive constitution, basic law and order, and an honest government leadership that calls the shots on investing in education, health and infrastructure, and providing planks for massive inflows of foreign investment.

There is the hydro sector, there is the tourism sector. Nepal could do well in becoming a regional education hub for having a wonderful climate at least in the hills. Planned urbanization could be another boost to the economy. Wireless broadband over metro areas could spew a host of knowledge industries like software and long distance learning. Get federalism, get the constitution, and get going, I say.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, July 08, 2013

The Only Alliance The Madhesi Parties Need

English: politician of nepal
English: politician of nepal (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
The only alliance the Madhesi parties really need is with each other. The Madhesi parties have to go to the people with the confidence that they will go into power no matter who forms the government at the center. Despite the Madhesi movement the Madhesi parties only got one third of the seats and votes in the Terai the last time around. It was because there was no hope they might go into power. Now the Madhesi people have seen that the Madhesi parties are the party of power. That opens doors. Should a Madhesi alliance be formed with the bottomline that there will be only one common candidate in each constituency the Madhesi parties might be able to cross the 50% mark in both votes and seats in the Terai. That will be a major victory. I think they stand to further weaken the Congress in the Terai and they will eat into the Maoist votes. The Maoists will eat into the UML votes and will still emerge strong in the Terai, and that is a good thing. The Madhesis and the Maoists are both federal forces.

There has been some talk of an alliance with the Nepali Congress. Unless the NC makes a clear ideological move and comes forth for a two state map for the Terai, I don't see how any alliance is possible, either pre-poll or post-poll. The NC's anti-federal stance is the reason the last Constituent Assembly died without completing its task.

Poll alliance elusive in dearth of Madhesi parties’ ideology
There cannot be a UCPN (Maoist) without Baburam Bhattarai
Dishanirdesh with Upendra Yadav - Mar 28, 2013
Dishanirdesh with Gagan Thapa- June 20, 2013
Dahal in ‘crisis’ as ‘pressure’ mounts

The most important ‘uneasy alliance’ in Nepali politics
UCPN (M) straining every nerve to take in ‘carefree’ Bhattarai
Dahal at Dhulikhel contemplating organizational proposal

TMDP renews Madhesi unity call
Madhesi parties' unification plan hits roadblock
Unification talks moving ahead positively: Thakur

I am not Rambo, says Nitish Kumar
Nitish Kumar does not believe in doing 'nautanki' like Narendra Modi: JD(U)
Two-third majority in CA poll must: Bhattarai
Bhattarai resignation won't affect polls: Agni Sapkota
Sex tape destroyed my faith in men, says Paris Hilton
The chairman will follow suit
Govt allows Super Madi Hydropower to bring foreign investment
Bolivian leader's plane rerouted on Snowden fear

Armed outfit, Sadhbhawana merge
Dahal-led FDRA fails to form poll alliance
SJTMM, Sadbhawana Party merge
NC‚ Madhesi forces may join hands for polls
Can Madhesi parties unite to form a single force?
Madhesi parties aspire to become national parties
Madhesi parties eyeing hill districts

Violent polls on the cards
Sadbhawana parties to unite: Jha
MPRF-D merging with TMDP: Gachchhadar
Giri's SP, NSP and TMDP-N set to unify
Single Madhesh province not possible: Gachchhadar
Bhattarai threatens to quit party vice-chair
Big parties trash 'One Madhes' idea, support separate Mithila state
Madhesi parties eyeing hill districts

Dahal meets Baidya, urges latter for party unification

Gachchadhar tries to woo FSP as alliance of poll-opposing parties starts to disintegrate
FDRA hails announcement of poll date

JP Gupta likely to join TMDP

Madhesi leaders rule out alliance based on sentiment
Just 4 Madhesi parties will survive: Analysts
Upendra Yadav´s Madhesi Janaadhikar Forum Nepal (MJF-N), the Madhesi Janaadhikar Forum (Loktantrik) of Bijaya Gachchhedar, Mahanta Thakur´s Tarai Madhes Loktantrik Party (TMLP) and Nepal Sadbhawana Party (NSP) led by Rajendra Mahato
MPRF-D, MPRF-R merger on cards, claim Madhesi leaders

The Koirala complex

BJP leader Advani resigns
Prabhu launches largest merger in banking sector

Bypoll loss would not impact NDA alliance: Nitish Kumar
Morcha ready to quit stance against threshold: Gachchhadar
Madhesi, Janajati alliance issues 7-day ultimatum to govt
Nitish Kumar hands out huge raises in Bihar

Baban Singh, other Madhesi leaders join MPRF
Mahato for separate poll alliance

Predators and prejudice

YCL to be reactivated as CA poll nears

Dahal steering party toward mass base
Majority Madhesi leaders snub Thakur's gathering
Sadbhawana Party calls off protest
The situation is not favorable for polls

महन्थ ठाकुरको नेतृत्वमा नयाँ पार्टीको सम्भावना छ : शरत्सिंह भण्डारी (अध्यक्ष–राष्ट्रिय मधेश समाजवादी पार्टी)
मधेशमा अलगाववादी र पलायनवादी चिन्तनको विकास हुँदैछ : रामेश्वर राय यादव (वरिष्ठ उपाध्यक्ष–मधेशी जनअधिकार फोरम, नेपाल (लोकतान्त्रिक)
As UML falters, party rank and file miss Madan Bhandari

Madheshi forces deliberating unity
NEFIN drops demand for single ethnic identity based
Sharif poised to form next Pakistan government

Pressure on Madhesi parties to go to polls in tandem
Electoral alliance of Madhesi parties unavoidable
Mahato hints of Madhesi alliance
Alliance forging: Easier said than done

Interview: How Ray Kurzweil Plans To Revolutionize Search At Google
Marissa Mayer Explains Yahoo's New Approach To Advertising
Poll deal could make Imran Khan PM
On Pakistan's campaign trail with Imran Khan
Imran Khan on election campaign trail

HLPC won't become legitimate if we join

FDF puts 13 demands before govt
Maoists and Madhesi alliance is unholy, claims Madhav
Will UCPN-M gain at cost of Madhesi parties?
Dahal suffering cataract problem, says Mahesh Basnet
Nepal: Maoists and Madhesi alliance may split nation, opines Rawal
UCPN (Maoist) will take nat'l leadership: Dahal
Madhesi Maoist leaders press for ‘respectable posts’
Electoral alliance of Madhesi parties unavoidable

More trouble for Sanjay Dutt, non-bailable warrant issued
Sanjay Dutt not willing to go to jail, finally challenges SC
Nitish Kumar's secular credentials surprise me: Akhilesh
Iran condemns the Boston bombing, with a caveat
Outrage in India as a billionaire receives special police protection
Reese Witherspoon arrested: report
Minister positive about talks with MJF-N-led alliance
It's UCPN (Maoist) Vs NC from now on: Dahal

Authorities announce Boston bombing suspect in custody
Electoral alliance with UML possible: Poudel

Breakfast with Maggie
China's concern with federalism is disintegration risk: Dahal
No statute without prez, speaker from our party: Bhattarai

Does Nitish Kumar Need the B.J.P.?
Hillary Clinton pens tribute to Obama
Musharraf Flees a Court–and Puts Pakistan’s Generals in a Quandary

No alliance with UML, Maoists, or Madhesis
Why Maoist parties have jumbo CCs
Baidya under fire over proposed CC nominations

Madhav Nepal's lone fight for punctuality
'Madhes key to NC glory'
Bhattarai rules out prospect of partylessness in country
Regmi says polls in mid-Dec
The human Thatcher
UML responsible for CA's demise
Enhanced by Zemanta