The only full timer out of the 200,000 Nepalis in the US to work for Nepal's democracy and social justice movements in 2005-06.
Friday, June 29, 2012
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Does Federalism Lead To A Bigger Government?
The Articles of Confederation, ratified in 1781. This was the format for the United States government until the Constitution. (Photo credit: Wikipedia) |
That is not how federalism works. Federalism is a more efficient form of government. Which means government expenses will actually go down. How so? Many of the functions of the unitary government in Kathmandu will be handed over to the states. That will lead to the elimination of some ministries and the downsizing of others.
Federalism done right is supposed to lead to an overall smaller bureaucracy.
Related articles
- Anti-federalists beware‚ says RJP
- Drive against anti-federalists
- Ethnic agitation shuts down Nepal
- Rallies for‚ against ethno-federalism
- Forging a Nepal for all its peoples
- Ministry aims at special tax on cement for rural electrification
- Nepal, without constitutional rudder, drifts into peril
- Arun Shrivastava: The Political Crisis in Nepal
Attacks On Federalism Mounting
English: PM Bhattarai during a live talk show. (Photo credit: Wikipedia) |
It would make sense for that all party government to be led by the party that was the largest in the last parliament. As in, it would make great sense for Baburam Bhattarai to continue being Prime Minister. So the effort towards an all party government is merely an exercise in adding a few members of the NC and the UML to the current cabinet. I don't think the Bhattarai government is opposed to that.
The NC and the UML misunderstand the concept of consensus. If due process had been allowed, the country today would already have had a constitution. More than two thirds of the last constituent assembly had lined up to give the country meaningful federalism. But the Bahun leaders of the NC and the UML who - let's face it - never willingly went for the idea of a constituent assembly, played roughshod with due process leading to the demise of the constituent assembly.
To allow one of those Bahuns, be it Sushil Koirala or KP Oli, to lead an all party government at this juncture would be to reward those who need to be punished. You can't reward those who do not believe in due process. These are anti federalist forces who, given enough space, will get rid of the concept of federalism itself.
The constitutional option is for Baburam Bhattarai to continue as Prime Minister and be open to bringing in some members of the NC and the UML into the cabinet which I believe he is. The political option is to take the country to fresh elections and before that help drive the Madhesis and Janajatis out of the NC and the UML and thus lead to an utter demise of these two anti federalist parties.
Baburam Bhattarai proved skillful on the army integration issue. His challenge now has become bigger. If he caves into the illegal NC, UML demands for his ouster, he will have pushed the country into a constitutional vacuum out of which unintended consequences might arise. Right now some space has been taken by the anti federalism forces. A constitutional vacuum will give space to the anti republican forces. Next thing you know we are going back to the 1990 constitution, which is what the NC and the UML leaders have wanted all along. That can not be allowed.
And if the NC and the UML will not join the current government to give it an all party face, the current caretaker government has to take the country into elections anyhow. I don't think the NC and the UML have the option to boycott the elections where they will be soundly defeated. They will emerge smaller than they were in the last constituent assembly.
Related articles
- UML seeks unity govt till polls
- Bhattarai must quit to pave way for a national unity government
- UML leaders rant against Maoist in Rolpa
- 'What PM said is party's official line'
- Bhattarai-led Cabinet will run daily affairs: Prez
- TMDP fears further polarisation could lead to autocracy
- Yadav under fire from Madhesis
- PM Bhattarai to return home today
- Nepal's CA fails to write Constitution
- UML chair Khanal set to knock Prez's door
- UML downplays Baidhya's warning of people's revolt
- Nepal stares at constitutional crisis as party positions harden
- I'll stay till election of next CAâ says Bhattarai
- An opportunity squandered
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)