Monday, May 23, 2005

Maoist Military Victory Vs Roundtable Conference With The Maoists


There are three political forces in the country: Monarchists, Maoists, democrats. So far each has been operating independent of the other, although attempts have been made by each camp to get one or the other to join them. The king in the past has tried to get the democrats to join him against the Maoists. The Maoists have constantly tried to get the democrats to join them to throw away the monarchy. And the democrats, mainly the Nepali Congress, in the past has tried to use the king's army against the Maoists, without success.

The stalemate continues as each camp seems to think it can gain more ground by refusing to enter into dialogue. Seeking dialogue has been thought of as a sign of weakness.

The king has expanded his personal power base as seen in increased state allowances to the royal family and his current direct rule. The Maoists have broken up the scant state structure in much of the countryside and can be said to be in de facto control. Both the guns have expanded their power bases at the expense of the democrats.

The democrats, on their part, have done nothing much to steal the political and social thunder of the Maoists. And they have not come anywhere close to republicanism so as to hit back at the monarchy ideologically.

So far the Monarchists are center stage. It is as if the insurgency has been a boon to them. Royalist ministers talk as if they expect the king's direct rule to stay on for at least three years, perhaps beyond.

The king, on his part, seems eager to soothe the rough edges, make cosmetic changes, but make no basic compromise. Chances are he will not be able to fool the international community, his target audience. Instead he is alienating the two forces he will end up having to do business with as things hot up.

The king seems to be counting too much on the fact that the Maoists might have been quite a menace, but they are nowhere close to taking over any of the district headquarters, let alone the national capital.

That is where the newly launched democratic movement comes in. The parties don't have guns. But street demonstrations can go a long way. If the king will not listen to reason, he will perhaps listen to the streets.

The Monarchist strategy seems to be do deal with the Maoists politically only if their military victory is imminent. By then, it might be too late. And that strategy does not take into account the democrats, a force slow to warm up, but once it does, it is the strongest.

In The News
  • New libraries spring up in Nepal's furthest corners Christian Science Monitor Foreigners come to Nepal expecting a land of magic, mountains, and Brad Pitt...... until the 1960s, access to education was limited to the royal family and its retinue....... It costs about $20,000 to build each library and to supply it with 3,000 to 5,000 books written in Nepali and English..... the Jhuwani library's new computer center, where a dozen terminals and workstations were arrayed in as orderly a fashion as they would be in any suburban high school classroom in the United States.
  • Nepal’s civil war: from security to politics Open Democracy, UK some sort of political rapprochement between the wayward and outdated Nepali political parties and the monarchy might take place .... these parties and their leaders have nothing much to offer except “protest and demonstration”, which in the present circumstances is only going to strengthen the rebels ..... India.. fears that in a few years some of its own states (Bihar and Andhra Pradesh) will be as red as Nepal.....prioritises stability rather than democracy in Nepal..... The Maoist movement is not going to wither away. It is a real political problem that needs real work to solve and the solution will only come through negotiation...... A new factor in this situation is the Nepali diaspora and a new generation ..... diasporas now play a great role both in fomenting and containing the conflict..... The fundamental characteristic of the Nepali state, since its very formation in 1768, is that of conflict within the ruling class...... all the achievements went swiftly downhill when the first Nepali Congress government poured cold water on the spirit of the people’s movement ...... Not one post-1990 government completed its term in office ..... The social alienation based on caste, religion, ethnicity, gender and uneven and centralised development policy all helped fuel the movement...... Charismatic leaders like Baburam Bhattarai ..... These young people, indoctrinated by a Maoist rhetoric of a utopian, just society, took up arms against their own clans while the ruling class in Kathmandu remained in deep slumber...... Central governments in Kathmandu regarded the situation as a law-and-order rather than a political challenge, and started to suppress the movement. They never tried to correct their own mistakes and bring Maoists into the mainstream..... Nepali political parties and governments..... failed to establish good relationships with Nepal’s bureaucracy, monarchy and security forces (all of which have grossly discredited the image of successive governments)...... For the government, it is terrorism; to the Maoist it is liberation from feudal rule; for some others it is a case of “revolutionary romanticism”...... the insurgency as a communist revolution or as an ethnic alliance against high-caste, Hindu-dominated political elite...... not an ideological war because Maoists have always been willing to come to terms ...... the assertive royal palace backed by the army ...... Rebellion was inevitable, given an environment of rampant corruption and injustice coupled with extreme poverty. ..... the excessive behaviour of post-1990s political leaders..... the role of the international community – particularly the US, Britain and India – in fuelling hostilities by supplying arms, cannot be dismissed. ...... The Maoist movement seems to have been supported by various clandestine revolutionary groups from neighbouring countries and beyond; and the international community’s ever-increasing interest in Nepal prompts speculation as to whether interference has worsened or helped mitigate the conflict..... Civil society, political parties and even the king have failed to bring these actors into a common platform to address the Maoist problem ..... unholy compromise between elected politicians and selected elites ..... parliamentary political parties (who in theory believe in representative democracy, but have neglected to assimilate social movements into the system) ...... the only chance for peace in Nepal lies not in “stability” but in a genuine democratic politics.
  • Largest Anti King Rally In Nepal SouthAsia Network Police in riot gear were posted around the market, but did not intervene.
  • Maoists bomb top army man's house in Nepal Sify, India Brigadier General Deepak Gurung's house in Kawasoti village, Nawalparasi district, southwestern Nepal, was "badly damaged in the bomb attack" ..... three suspected Maoists riding a motorcycle carried out the bombing before escaping ..... Maoists also attacked Gurung's house two years ago
  • ‘Land pooling started for 2nd int’l airport’ Gorkhapatra the government would build the second international airport of the country in Bhairahawa within three years ..... Gautam Buddha international airport .... the government would initiate development programme in Lumbini and the people would find it a different place within a year. .... no heritage sites of the Kathmandu valley would remain in dilapidated state in five-year time. ..... About the condition of the Royal Nepal Airlines Corporation (RNAC), he said that it had been affected by cancer
  • NEPAL: Rally organisers ask resignation of Gorkhapatra editor Asia Pacific Media Network, CA In a democracy, people are allowed to criticize. But to denounce one’s nationality and the head of one’s state is not a democratic value, he reportedly said....... Sujata Jost spent thousands of dollars to spread rumors about Nepal. On Sunday’s demonstration, she spent $50 a head to bring each person there .... Ganga Chaulagain, who has denied the quote
  • King’s army grapples with desertion Calcutta Telegraph, India ..... suspicions that the Royal Nepal Army (RNA) is manned by straw soldiers...... The king’s army is grappling with desertions forced by threats from Maoist rebels. For any army in the middle of a war, desertions are a corrosive danger...... “He told me that he had quit the RNA because it did not pay him enough to meet the extortionate demands of the Maobadi,” Mukarji said...... evidence from Nepal on the weakness of the RNA has been mounting...... estimated the total number of desertions by RNA soldiers at “between 200 and 300 a month”..... ..... “the insurgency has riven families”....... Mehta estimated that the Maoists’ army had a strength of 8,000 to 12,000 fighters but only 4,000 weapons. “They have the power of intimidation, the power to strike fear but very little fire-power.” ..... RNA .... some of its best and most important fighting units are stationed inside the Narayanhiti compound in Kathmandu and are effectively a palace guard....... the RNA has improved its defensive tactics but it is not taking the battle to the Maoists. ..... Of late, the Maoists have targeted the families of Royal Nepal Army personnel. They have extorted money, locked up the houses and seized the property of RNA personnel. As a result, the families of RNA personnel have been impelled to flee their villages overnight to safer places ...... The violence against the families of RNA personnel has increased especially in the insurgency-hit districts ...... The RNA says altogether 292 families of RNA personnel have fled their villages since February 1
  • The Nepal Problem The Asian Wall Street Journal .... now more than 100 days since King Gyanendra unleashed his assault on democracy ..... instated emergency powers that made Nepal effectively an absolute monarchy ..... The Maoist rebellion has continued largely unabated ..... the only bright note of the 100 days was that the Maoists and the royal government both agreed to allow the United Nations to deploy a relatively robust human-rights monitoring mission in the field ..... Nobody wants Nepal to collapse under a Maoist onslaught, and the king has done everything he can to paint himself as the last bastion of defense against the Maoists...... One hundred days of royal rule have proven that the king was being honest when he said he did not have much of a plan
  • Statement By 25 Human Rights Organizations INSN ..... should the regime appoint members of the NHRC, they would engage in pleasing the current regime, completely undermining the indispensable norms of the Paris Principles such as independence, impartiality, efficiency and professionalism...... attempt of the regime to enforce the “Amendment to Nepal Acts related to Media Laws” that aim to curtail free and fair news reporting and publication..... demonstrate the actual end of the “state of emergency.”
  • When A Family's Future Is On The Line The Washington Post My father-in-law has vowed that if the Maoists ever try to force his grandchildren into their ranks, “I have a sword, I’m an old man, and I’m not afraid of dying.” ..... my father-in-law, a village priest, had chanted through much of the 26-hour flight to ensure the plane stayed in the air .......My mother-in-law had never before seen a traffic light, but was soon asking trenchant questions about American life: Why was it that only women seemed to work as store clerks? Why are all the road workers black? ...... Soldiers were coming by day and warning, “You’re either with us, or with the terrorists.” Rebels came by night and said the same thing. ....... An entire village of low-caste potters’ huts near our village was reportedly burned to the ground....... There must be countless Washington families who have gone through these same tense moments: Rwandans, Sudanese, Peruvians, Guatemalans. ...... my mother was in elementary school when the Nazis swept through Poland, where most of her family still lived...... when armed men are bent on violence, there’s nothing a relative half a world away can do....... The mob went on its way, the soldiers still marching beside them.
  • Syangja: Maoists Preparing To Take Students INSN Maoists are training the students in different schools of village areas in the name of giving janabadi (people’s) education...... a Maoist cadre had ordered girl students to cut their hair and wear jeans pants ...... A student said they would come and select the strong students and take those students with them. ...... he just said it is a time of war between two rifles, so the people may need to bear risk and in the war for their right they may need to pay a high price at any cost also
  • Mass Meeting Pamphlet INSN
  • Fear Of Freedom Or Freedom From Fear CK Lal Nepali Times Madhab Nepal ... he wants the future of monarchy to be a topic of national debate. ..... Sher Bahadur Deuba ....He was persuaded that a chronically squabbling parliament was a hindrance to fight the Maoist menace...... Whatever you may say about Girija Prasad Koirala, at least he has been consistent in his main demand – restoration of parliament as a point of departure for progressive changes in the polity. Now, seven mainstream parties representing 95 percent of parliamentary strength have supported this demand. The Europeans, Indians and the Americans welcomed this new-found unity among the parties and have finally realised the folly of supporting the needless political experiments of the last three years...... the head-in-the-sand attitude of Kathmandu’s ruling elite about February First persists ..... flex administrative and financial muscle to muzzle the media in excesses that transcend the Panchayat. ..... 22 May 2002—the day Deuba dismantled parliament and announced elections he knew could never be held. ...... The royal takeover is defended by fanning fears of a Maoist takeover. ...... a democratic and progressive Nepal is sure to emerge from this churning........ it’s time to restore due process under the constitution through a reactivated lower house.
  • Parties Protest Nationwide NepalNews.com ...... reinstatement of the dissolved House of Representatives, formation of an interim government to hold peace talks with the Maoists and hold constituent assembly elections to draft a new constitution, if necessary...... Though security was on high alert, there was no intervention during the rally...... thousands participated in peaceful protests in Biratnagar, Jankapur, Birgunj, Jaleswor, Gaur, Malangwa, Pokhara and Dhangadi.
  • Trouble In The Mountain Kingdom Humanscape.org .....India is a key player in Nepal and has, by oiling the monarchical-army machinery from late 2001, contributed to the crisis..... investing so blithely on the force that is on the losing side of history ...... 1 February 2005 can only be described as a royal military-palace coup...... The king was not constrained by the constitution of 1990 since its provisions were not adequate to prevent a monarch from defeating its very spirit and letter...... the Maoists seemed to only get stronger ...... Nepal registering the highest number of newly recorded disappearances in the world, rapes, extra-judicial killings, torture, displacement, illegal arrests and detentions ...... state actors registered the victory in accumulating the figures ...... The Maoists had guns, but were ideological and political. The RNA had only guns and the aim of preserving status quo. It was not an equal battle...... The problem is with the structure of the RNA. It is an unprofessional fighting force, with a feudal structure, fit for ceremonial functions, at best as a palace army..... The Nepali official language is only known to 42 per cent contributing to a 60-70 per cent failure rate in the school leaving certificate...... the biggest obstacle to the peace process is the monarchy-army. ......
  • Of Holes In Socks And Blank Newspapers Humanscape.org Take a good measure of emergency flour. Sift thoroughly to remove all resistance. Knead with exhortations of national security. Grill and set aside. Wash a dozen journalists and wring thoroughly. Don’t forget to strip away fundamental rights before you pop them into boiling water. Add a liberal measure of censorship guidelines. Sprinkle a dash of detentions. Grate a generous amount of intimidation. Stir in a few threats to withdraw advertisements and licenses. Simmer on low flame. Garnish with rhetoric of ‘tackling the Maoist problem’. Serve hot.

Sunday, May 22, 2005

Streets Filling Up


This is great. The first day of the movement has been heartening. Just when things are heating up in Bihar as well.

I have also noted with interest Manisha Koirala's father's ouster from the Congress. The guy apparently gave an interview suggesting there is nothing in the 1990 constitution that allows for a reinstatement of the parliament, which apparently happens also to be my line. Forget the 1999 parliament, and forget the 1990 constitution.

There are three camps. If you are not for the king's move of 2/1, you are against peace and for terrorism, the Monarchists will tell you. If you are not for reviving the parliament, you are against democracy, the democrats will tell you. If you are not with Prachanda, you are against the Maoist party, the Maoists tell the Maoists like Baburam.

These hardliner stands are great for group cohesion in the three camps, but they are a major disservice to the cause of peace. All three camps will have to soften if peace is to be possible.

And if the Gulf News story reported in the Telegraph is to be believed, Baburam is back go doing business on behalf of his party. That is great news. Baburam is back in the swing. The guy is a progressive more than he is a textbook Maoist. He is capable of having a moderating influence on the Maoists without selling away the basic progressive thrust of the party. He is reasonable. It is possible to talk to him.

The letter by the three human rights organizations to Prachanda is meaningful. Human rights monitoring, to which both the army and the Maoists have agreed to, is the only and best hope to end the conflict on the table for now. That option has to be exploited to the fullest.

In The News
  • Bihar Assembly dissolved Times of India
  • Despite cold vibes, Indian diplomat on way to Nepal Indian Express, India
  • No end in sight to Nepal's woes Bangkok Post .....the country has far from regained the normalcy King Gyanendra promised to bring within 100 days ..... Gyanendra had ``achieved a fantastic way of exercising control over almost every aspect of life'' ..... 1,516 individuals are still detained. Among the most prominent is Sher Bahadur Deuba ...... Other prominent detainees include student leader Gagan Thapa and former minister J P Gupta, who were re-arrested on May 5....... the problem ultimately has to be solved by the Nepalese ..... the crisis is an opportunity for the Nepalese people to come out and say what they want
  • Opposition protests around Nepal BBC News Protesters want the reinstatement of the dissolved parliament and the formation of an all-party government...... Biratnagar, Janakpur and Pokhara...... The opposition parties argue that an all-party government would create an environment for holding peace negotiations with the Maoist insurgents..... opposition leaders say restoration of peace is not possible unless people's democratic rights are restored first.
  • More than 10,000 rally in Nepal's capital; largest anti-king rally ... Santa Fe New Mexican
  • Manisha’s royalist father gets party boot Calcutta Telegraph Prakash Koirala was today expelled from the Nepali Congress for toeing the royalist line ..... the party was founded by Prakash’s father B.P. Koirala and is now headed by his uncle and three-time Prime Minister, Girija Prasad Koirala ...... the toughest action taken by the party against a senior leader after the expulsion of former Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba on May 26 2002 ...... forced to act after Prakash gave an interview to the English daily The Himalayan Times yesterday opposing the party’s demand for reinstatement of the House of Representatives. He argued that such a move would be against the spirit of the constitution and suggested a round table conference to discuss the issue ...... He also said that since the Supreme Court has quashed a writ challenging the dissolution of the House of Representatives, there was no point in pursuing the idea any further...... a member of the Central Working Committee
  • Nepal's army gears up to better rights record:- Webindia123, India Dogged by allegations of human rights violations and the spectre of a permanent embargo on foreign military aid, Nepal's army has announced a clutch of "positive steps" ..... welcomed the setting up of a monitoring office in the capital by the UN Office of High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and was ready to provide access to detention sites ...... "We also hope they would show up the human rights abuses committed by the Maoist insurgents and help push them towards peace talks"...... Besides the UN agency, it said its detention sites were also open to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) as well as Nepal's National Human Rights Commission...... the army said it would have a national central registry of detainees to keep track of people under arrest...... The army's home page on the Internet has a human rights section through which complaints can also be made anonymously...... the RNA said tainted soldiers will not be sent to UN missions.
  • Maoists say Prachanda tape is 'propaganda':- Webindia123 ..... the rebels issued a statement that described the tape's contents as "witless propaganda". ..... Prachanda issued a statement Sunday, admitting it was his voice on the tape but clarifying it was an earlier tape and not relevant to the current times.
  • Nepal Army plays tape saying India in league with Nepal Maoists Newindpress
  • Nepal Democracy Movement: A scene from the rally. Pic by Chandra ... United We Blog, Nepal .....In an encouraging beginning of Jana Andolan 2062, at least five thousand pro-democracy activists rallied in heart of Kathmandu demanding restoration of democracy and civil liberties in Nepal. Activists from all seven political parties of the recently launched United Front ..... Riot police were stationed on all the corners- on way to Dillibazzar, on way to Ghanta Ghar, on way to Baghbazzar and on way to Jay Nepal Hall....... In front of Democracy Wall in Baghbazzar, a truck full of riot police was parked. Police were moving around....... A big truck and at least 50 police were standing at the Bhotahitti Chowk...... Being in the rally is always a strange experience for me. I mean you feel aroused, energized. Blood starts circulating fast...... all most all participants of the rally were hard core political activists...... Did that mean the rally had no public support? ...... “Well, they definitely don’t have public support,” shop keeper Prabin Tuladhar, 35, told me...... “The rally is not different to that of 2046,” he told me, “people didn’t come in the beginning at that time too. I think the momentum will gain momentum in the days to come.” ..... Yogesh Upadhaya of CPN UML was on the microphone. He spoke of the need of unity among democratic forces and continue fighting for full democracy. Then spoke Hari Bol Bhattarai, a NC leader. “The King should be constitutional. Parliament should be restored. People should rule over themselves.” ...... KP Oli, a CPN UML heavyweight walking in Ason Chowk talking with someone over the cell phone.
  • Democracy protests in four Nepali cities CBC Kathmandu, Biratnagar, Janakpur and Pokhara ..... the political parties have demanded the monarch reinstate the dissolved parliament to allow a multiparty government to negotiate a political settlement with the insurgents...... more than 10,000 protesters gathered at Asan..... Hundreds of police in riot gear were posted around the market, but did not intervene...... future rallies, including one planned for Friday, would be bigger ..... The king lifted the emergency at the end of April and rallies are now allowed
  • Prachanda's Statement INSN
  • Delhi Sniffs King's Ploy Telegraph ...a report in Gulf News that some key Maoist leaders, including Baburam Bhattarai, held meetings with CPI leader A.B. Bardhan and his CPM counterpart Prakash Karat recently ..... the army, prompted by the king, was “trying to play hardball” ..... Neither the king nor his close aides took the Indian statement lightly. The palace, unhappy with critical reports that have appeared in the Indian media in the past few weeks, feels these reflect the view of the government.
  • Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, International Commission of Jurists Write To Prachanda INSN .....an ongoing wave of human rights abuses by Maoist forces over the last few months casts serious doubts on the credibility of your repeated public commitments to that effect..... in a press release of 5 April 2005 the CPN (Maoist) publicly called for an international human rights monitoring presence in Nepal ...... the CPN (Maoist) also pledged to cooperate fully with any such mission, if established, and to be answerable for any human rights abuses by CPN (Maoist). On 12 April, you personally reiterated the pledge to fully support and cooperate with any human rights monitors ..... On 16 May 2005, Shanker Sarki, a soldier, who had returned home from Congo where he had served in the United Nations Peacekeeping Forces, was abducted from his home in Dhangadi, Kailali district by 12 armed Maoist cadres in civilian dress and killed...... Specifically, we call on to publicly to prohibit CPN (Maoist) forces from engaging in targeting civilians and civilian objects and carrying out indiscriminate attacks, arbitrary killings, torture and other ill-treatment, taking hostages and recruiting child soldiers. We also call on you to remove from their post any CPN (Maoist) cadres who are responsible for human rights abuses....... With reference to your interview of 18 April, we remind you that the civil war in Nepal falls under the purview of international humanitarian law. Among the fundamental protections during internal armed conflicts are those contained in Common Article Three in the four Geneva Conventions of 1949, regarding the treatment of persons taking no active part in the hostilities. This article prohibits, among other things, summary executions, torture and other ill-treatment, the taking of hostages, and punishment without fair trial. Credible information indicates that CPN (Maoist) forces routinely violate Common Article Three by engaging in brutal and abusive activities against civilians and others not taking active part in hostilities....... Common Article Three binds both states parties and insurgent groups. Adherence is not based on reciprocity ...... arguments set out in the interview published on 18 April that RNA abuses “outnumber” abuses by your forces or that your ideology justifies your actions in no way exempt you and your forces from your obligations under international law....... mechanisms to allow transparent and independent investigations by the UN teams in areas under (CPN) Maoist control ...... each side is responsible for the conduct of its own forces
  • India Should Talk To Maoists: Gen. Mehta Nepalnews.com it is true that India is trying to talk to (Nepali) Maoists ..... Speaking in Nepali language ..... “As India is holding dialogue with Nepali (parliamentary) parties, there should be no problem in holding dialogue with the Maoists” ..... even from the point of view of `balance of power’ (within Nepal) it was important that the Maoists army did not disintegrate...... Indian authorities have been saying, of late, that Maoist problem has emerged as the no. 1 internal security problem in the country.